Modeling Causality

Instructions: Read the description of the relationships among the variables in each of the cases below. Then, using the concepts discussed in class, attempt to diagram that relationship using the appropriate symbology and labels for independent variable, dependent variable, moderating variable, antecedent variable, and confounding variable.

Case One -- A researcher believes that gender influences the extent of verbal aggressiveness displayed by an individual, with males being more verbally aggressive than females.











Case Two -- A second researcher believes that an individual's status is the primary determinant of his or her verbal aggressiveness, and that such aggressiveness increases with status. However, gender influences this relationship in such a way that the increase in verbal aggressiveness for any increment of increase in status is greater for men than for women.











Case Three -- A third researcher believes that verbal aggressiveness is higher for men than for women, on average, and that verbal aggressiveness increases as status increases.















Case 4 -- A researcher theorizes that family communication patterns influence the conflict-resolution strategies adopted by children in other settings -- at school, with friends, and so forth. She notes that both family communication patterns and conflict resolution strategies can be ranked by the extent to which they are socio-oriented -- that is, geared toward the "smoothing over" or suppression of anger, hostility, and conflict, and predicts that children from families characterized by highly socio-oriented communication patterns will adopt more socio-oriented conflict resolution strategies. However, the researcher is unable to rule out the possibility that both family communication patterns and children's conflict resolution strategies are not in fact causally related, but are both influenced by parents' attitude toward conflict.












Case 5 -- A researcher posits a mechanism whereby the existence of "family friendly policies" such as flex-time, parental leave, and on-site daycare within an organization will improve that organization's productivity. He suspects that increases in the number, usefulness, and accessibility of such policies will result in increases in worker morale, which will then serve to increase productivity.











Case 6 -- A researcher is unable to rule the possibility that propensity toward violence is not caused by viewing violent television, but is in fact determined by the prevalence of violence within the community to which an individual belongs.











Back to Handouts and Exercises